Tim Pool vs. Liquid Death: Why the “Plastic in Cans” Debate Misses the Bigger Picture

Tim Pool vs. Liquid Death: Why the “Plastic in Cans” Debate Misses the Bigger Picture

Tim Pool vs. Liquid Death: The Debate Over Plastic — and Why It’s Not That Simple

You may have seen the recent debate between accomplished YouTuber and businessman Tim Pool and the CEO of Liquid Death, where Pool challenged the company’s “Death to Plastic” slogan. Pool's main point? Despite the marketing message, Liquid Death’s aluminum cans still contain plastic liners to prevent corrosion and flavor contamination.

For many viewers, that was a “gotcha” moment, but for those of us in the packaging industry, it simply confirmed what we already know: not every beverage or product can move away from plastic, especially at scale.

At Sailor Plastic Bottles in Adrian, MN, we’ve built our business around producing PET bottles for food, beverage, and industrial uses. We specialize in low-quantity runs and a high mix of bottle styles, giving brands flexibility without massive minimums. That hands-on experience gives us a front-row seat to the real-world limits of “plastic-free” packaging.

1️⃣ Every product has unique packaging requirements

Different contents demand different materials. It’s not about which material looks better. It’s about what performs best for the product inside.

  • Some beverages can’t be stored in metal or glass due to corrosion, UV sensitivity, or taste transfer.
  • Metal cans almost always require polymer liners (plastic coatings) to prevent product contact with metal, exactly what Tim Pool called out.
  • Glass is heavy, breakable, and often inefficient to transport.
  • PET plastic provides a lightweight, safe, and durable barrier for many liquids and formulations.

Bottom line: not every product can safely, efficiently, or economically use non-plastic materials.

2️⃣ “Death to Plastic” vs. packaging reality

Liquid Death’s branding has been wildly successful, but Tim Pool’s critique exposed an uncomfortable truth: even “plastic-free” packaging often still relies on plastic components.

Here’s the nuance most consumers miss:

  • Cans, cartons, and closures often use plastic liners, seals, or gaskets.
  • These materials are essential for product safety and performance.
  • Eliminating them entirely would risk shelf life, contamination, or cost explosions.

That doesn’t make a brand deceptive. It highlights the complexity of packaging engineering.

3️⃣ Scale changes everything

Designing one prototype in glass or metal is easy. Running full-scale production across multiple SKUs and locations? That’s another story.

Changing materials affects tooling, machinery, lead times, recyclability, and freight costs. PET offers the most balanced solution, especially for smaller and mid-sized brands that need flexibility, not rigid minimums.

At Sailor Plastic Bottles, that’s our specialty:

  • Short-run, high-mix production keeps brands nimble.
  • Case-packed PET bottles simplify inventory and distribution.
  • PET’s established recycling infrastructure supports long-term sustainability goals.

It’s a formula that keeps our customers competitive and grounded in what actually works.

4️⃣ Plastic isn’t the problem — poor design is

Plastic isn’t the villain. Poor design and weak recycling systems are.

Well-designed PET bottles often outperform alternatives in carbon footprint, transport efficiency, and energy use when you look at the full lifecycle. The focus should be on smart use, recyclability, and responsible sourcing, not slogans.

At Sailor, we focus on producing high-quality, American-made PET bottles that balance practicality, performance, and sustainability, helping real brands package real products responsibly.

💡 The takeaway

The Tim Pool vs. Liquid Death debate reminded everyone that packaging isn’t black and white.
Even “plastic-free” solutions rely on plastics somewhere in the process.

For manufacturers and brands alike, the message is clear: don’t demonize materials. Choose the right one for the job.

At Sailor Plastic Bottles, we’re proud to make durable, case-packed PET bottles for brands that need reliability, flexibility, and real-world performance, not marketing gimmicks.

🏭 About Sailor Plastic Bottles

Sailor Plastic Bottles is a U.S.-based manufacturer located in Adrian, Minnesota, producing high-quality PET bottles for the food, beverage, and industrial markets. We specialize in low-quantity runs and high-mix production, providing dependable American-made packaging that helps brands stay flexible and competitive.

Back to blog